Unofficial fan projectSeaver, the Miracle, and Two Pennants
John Milner
First baseman and left fielder · Mets 1971–1977

The part fans remember
What the numbers leave out.
Milner was a powerful left-handed bat who gave the Mets another dangerous hitter around Seaver and the pitching staff. He could play first base or left field, hit the ball out of Shea, and became one of the lineup’s most useful pieces before the 1977 breakup.
Milner gave the Mets a powerful left-handed bat just as the first championship core was finding its shape. He could play first base or left field, hit the ball out of Shea, and provide protection behind the best hitters. His game was not flashy, but the lineup looked more dangerous when he was healthy and locked in.
He led the Mets in home runs three straight seasons from 1972 through 1974 and produced a five-hit game as a rookie. In 1973, his power helped an injury-riddled club stay alive long enough for McGraw and Seaver to lead the late charge. Milner was not the face of the pennant, but he was one of the bats that made the comeback possible.
The 1977 trade of Tom Seaver began the breakup, and Milner was part of the group left to navigate the empty years. He was traded later that season, ending a Mets career that had included two pennants and a lot of hard outs. Fans remember him as a strong, useful hitter who never received quite enough credit for how much pressure he took off the stars around him.
The honest version
The best stretch
Milner’s peak gave the early-1970s Mets a left-handed power threat behind the stars. He led the club in home runs three straight seasons and could move between first base and left field. His swing was strong enough to change a game at Shea, which mattered on teams that often won by a run or two.
The part that got messy
The lineup needed his production in 1973, when injuries forced the Mets to search for offense wherever it could find it. Milner’s power did not make him a complete hitter, but it kept pitchers from treating the bottom half of the lineup as an automatic escape. His five-hit rookie game had already shown what his bat could do when everything lined up.
Why fans still care
The breakup after 1976 ended the chance for Milner to become part of another contender. He was traded during the 1977 collapse, leaving with two pennants and a reputation for being better than the short career totals suggest. In the first Mets golden age, he was one of the bats that made the pitching feel possible.
Signature Mets momentLed the Mets in home runs three straight seasons from 1972 through 1974.
The short list
The stuff worth remembering.
- 011973 National League champion
- 02Three straight seasons leading the Mets in home runs
- 03Five-hit game as a rookie